Syllabus

Title
1649 Course II - Theories in Ethics
Instructors
ao.Univ.Prof. Dr. Gabriele Mras
Contact details
Type
PI
Weekly hours
2
Language of instruction
Englisch
Registration
09/05/22 to 09/30/22
Registration via LPIS
Notes to the course
Subject(s) Bachelor Programs
Dates
Day Date Time Room
Wednesday 11/23/22 05:30 PM - 08:00 PM D4.0.127
Wednesday 11/30/22 05:30 PM - 08:30 PM D4.0.127
Wednesday 12/07/22 05:30 PM - 08:30 PM D4.0.127
Wednesday 12/14/22 05:30 PM - 08:30 PM D4.0.136
Wednesday 12/21/22 05:30 PM - 09:30 PM D4.0.019
Wednesday 01/11/23 02:30 PM - 09:30 PM D4.0.127
Contents

„Theories in Ethics” is an introduction into moral philosophy. The course focuses on the possibility of justifying criteria for the moral quality of an action. We will begin with Aristotle’s “Nicomachean Ethics”, move on to Immanuel Kant’s “Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals”, and will then discuss John Stuart Mill’s criticism of Kant’s approach and his own suggestions — in “Utilitarianism”  — of what could count as criterion for assessing what is morally right or wrong.

The questions we will pursue are: (1) Can eudaimonia, a „well lived“ life,  be regarded as final end of all our actions? (2) does Aristotle refer to human nature as a foundation of considerations about “what one ought to do”. If so, what is humans’ “nature” according to Aristotle? 3) What is “rationality” according to Kant? 4) What is for Kant the “supreme” principle of moral action? 5) Is it possible to deduce any criteria for assessing the rightness of an action from the formulae of the categorical imperative alone? (6) what is “utility” according to J. St. Mill? (7)  Is the greatest happiness determinable, i.e, can it represent a concrete goal in a society

Learning outcomes
  1. identify the basic theoretical problems in moral philosophy and the major approaches in the history of ethics
  2. critically analyze the foundations of ethical theory
  3. summarize in detail, both orally and in writing, the three major ethical theories
  4. evaluate the ways in which philosophers attempt to justify a criterion for acting morally
  5. try to apply the different ethical criteria in concrete cases 
  6. analyze the application suggested by others
Attendance requirements

The is a PI course (100% presence), which means that continuous assessment of student performance is carried out. Students will raise and answer questions in class and show further active participation (e.g. presentations) in class. It is a “blended learning” course, too. 

Teaching/learning method(s)

The course starts with a session in which administrative questions will be clarified. You will receive information about the structure of this course and should organize yourselves in “working” groups for the presentations.

I want everybody to stay “on board”, that’s why “weekly assignments” are a part of this course design. Please ask in the “Foren”, if some questions are unclear! There is a text on MyLEARN ("Lecture Text") available, which should help you with your assignments.

Additionally, you should create (in small groups of max. 4) short video interviews to see, how other people assess the moral quality of concrete situations, use ethical approaches, and come to ethical conclusions. Instructions for the assignments will be given and discussed in class. 

Written feedback from me is always provided in “Foren” on MyLEARN.

Assessment

1. 4 weekly assignments: 100 points (no grading according to a 1-5 scale, just „passed“ or not). Please honor the deadlines (see Learn), assignments that are turned in too late will receive less points: 1 day: 20%, 2 days: 50%.  2. group video presentations: 100 points (includes presentation of the interviews: 40 points, transcription of 1 interview: 20 points, written summary of the interpretation of all interviews: 40 points ). 3. Questions and comments in the "Foren" (or class contribution over the whole term). Full engagement is necessary in order to get compensatory 10 points here) 

Points in total 210:

Excellent (1): 198 - 210 points
Good (2): 160 - 197 points 
Satisfactory (3): 120 - 159 points
Sufficient (4): 80-119 points
Fail (5): <80

Readings

Please log in with your WU account to use all functionalities of read!t. For off-campus access to our licensed electronic resources, remember to activate your VPN connection connection. In case you encounter any technical problems or have questions regarding read!t, please feel free to contact the library at readinglists@wu.ac.at.

Recommended previous knowledge and skills

Some philosophical knowlege or having attended the LV "Logic and methodology of social sciences"

Availability of lecturer(s)

ao.Univ.Prof.Dr. Gabriele M. Mras
Building D4, 3rd floor, room number D4.3.020
Tel.: 01-31336-4257
Email: gabriele.mras@wu.ac.at

Administration: Bettina Gerdenich
Tel.: 01-31336-4166
Email: bettina.gerdenich@wu.ac.at

Unit details
Unit Date Contents
1 23.11.22: 17:30-20:00

Intro into class, course overview, required readings

2 30.11.22: 17:30-20:30

A) ARISTOTLE

  1. Introduction
  2. Three Kinds of Life
    Required reading: Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics, Book I
  3. Virtues Between Two Vices
  4. The Voluntary, Decision, and Responsibility
  5. The Virtues of Character
  6. Acting Against One’s Better Judgment
  7. Friendship
    Reading: Aristotele's Nicomachean Ethics, Books VIII
  8. What is the Best Kind of Life?
    Reading: Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics Book X
  9. Moral Virtue and Moral Psychology
    Reading: Korsgaard, The Constitution of Agency, Aristotle's Function Argument

B) (i) VIRTUE ETHICS  (ii) SOCIETY AND/OR HUMAN NATURE

  1. Sympathy and the General Point of the View
    Required reading: Hume, A Treatise of Human Nature, III.iii.1,3,6; Book I Part III and Book III Part I.
3 07.12.22: 17:30-20:30

C) KANT

  1. Acting from Duty
    Required reading: Kant, Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals, Preface and Section I
    Kant, Grundlegung zur Metaphyisk der Sitten, Vorrede
  2. The Categorical Imperative
    Required reading: Kant, Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals, Section II, through 4:424
    Kant, Grundlegung zur Metaphyisk der Sitten, Sektion 2
  3. The Kingdom of Ends
    Requried reading: Kant, Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals, Section II, 4:425-440
  4. Modern and Moral Philosophy
    Reading: Rawls, Lectures on the History of Moral Philosophy, Introduction: Modern and Moral Philosophy, 1600-1800
  5. Reading: Kant, Religion within the Boundaries of Mere Reason, Concerning the Battle of the Good against the Evil Principle for Dominion over the Human Being
  6. Critique of practical reason
    Reading: Kant, Practical philosophy, Critique of practical reason (1788)
  7. Moral Deliberation and the Derivation of Duties
    Reading: Herman, The Practice of Moral Judgment, Moral Deliberation and the Derivation of Duties
    4 14.12.22: 17:30-20:30

    C) CONSEQUENTIALISM vs. A PRIORI ACCOUNTS OF MORALITY

    1. The Foundation of Morality
      Reading: Kant, Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals, finish Section III
    2. Maxims and obligations
      Reading: O'Neill, Constructions of Reason: Explorations of Kant's Practical Philosophy, Consistency in action
    3. Happiness for Everyone
      Reading: Bentham, An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation, selections on course website; Mill, Utilitarianism, Chs. 1-2 and 8
    4. Mill Ultilitarianism
      Required reading: Mill ed. Bennett Utilitarianism, Chs. 1-5.
    5. The Idea of a Moral Science
    6. The "Greatest Good for All" and the Question of a usable Criterion
    7. The Foundations for Moral Relativism
      Reading: Velleman, Foundations for Moral Relativism, Ch. 5.
    8. Utilitarianism and the Virtues
      Reading: Foot, Utilitarianism and the Virtues
    9. A Critique of Utilitarianism
      Williams: A Critique of Utilitarianism
    10. Some Ordinalist-Utilitarian Notes on Rawls's Theory of Justice by John Rawls
      Kenneth: Some Ordinalist-Utilitarian Notes on Rawls's Theory of Justice by John Rawls
    5 21.12.22: 17:30-21:30

    D) Overview of the three ethical accounts presented, open discussion.

    1. Exhausted: How we can stop Lithium Mining from Depleting Water Resources, draining Wetlands, and Harming Communities in South America
      Reading: James J. A. Blair, Ramón M. Balcázar, Javiera Barandiarán, Amanda Maxwell: Exhausted: How we can stop Lithium Mining from Depleting Water Resources, draining Wetlands, and Harming Communities in South America
    2. The rush to go electric comes with a hidden cost destructive lithium mining
      Reading: Thea Riofrancos: The rush to go electric comes with a hidden cost destructive lithium mining
    3. The Paradox of Clean EVs and the Dirty Lithium Mining Business
      Reading: Christopher McFadden: The Paradox of Clean EVs and the Dirty Lithium Mining Business
    4. Lithium-Ion Battery Recycling The Complete Guide
      Reading: Nikola Geme: Lithium-Ion Battery Recycling The Complete Guide
    5. What Are the Biggest Misconceptions of Universal Basic Income
      Reading: Justin Heller: What Are the Biggest Misconceptions of Universal Basic Income
    6 11.01.23: 14:30- 17:00

    E) Presentation of moral deliberations.

    1. Electric Vehicles
      Reading: Oliver Balch, "The curse of 'white oil': electric vehicles' dirty secret | Electric, hybrid and low-emission cars"
      + Reading of your choice
    2. Social Media and Politics
      Reading: Brent Barnhart, "Social Media and Politics: Why It Matters & 10 Tips"
      + Reading of your choice
    3. Affirmative Action
      Reading: "What is affirmative action, anyway? 4 essential reads"
      + Reading of your choice
    4. Universal Basic Income
      Reading: Tera Allas, Jukka Maksimainen, James Manyika, Navjot Singh, "An experiment to inform universal basic income"
    5. Is Affirmative Action Doomed
      Reading: Ronald Dworkin, "Is Affirmative Action Doomed?"
      + Reading of your choice
    6. Affirming Affirmative Action
      Reading: Ronald Dworkin, "Affirming Affirmative Action"
      + Reading of your choice
    7. Basic Income as a Policy Option
      Reading: "Basic Income as a Policy Option: Technical Background Note Illustrating Costs and Distributional Implications for Selected Countries"
      + Reading of your choice
    8. Universal Basic Income Has Been
      Reading: Megan Greenwell "Universal Basic Income Has Been Tested Repeatedly. It Works. Will America Ever Embrace It? The extraordinary success and thorny politics of a bold policy idea"
      + Reading of your choice
    7 11.01.23: 17:30 - 21:30

    E) Discussion of the application of "our" ethical theories

    1. Agrarian Justice
      Reading: Thomas Paine: Agrarian Justice
    2. Rights of Man
      Reading: Thomas Paine: Rights of Man (1792)
    3. Primer on Universal Basic Income
      Reading: Primer on Universal Basic Income
    Last edited: 2022-12-21



    Back